HSA Value Analyzer

Evaluate the real value of an HSA-eligible health plan beyond the headline tax benefits. This tool estimates potential savings and tradeoffs using simplified assumptions.

HSA-Eligible Plan

Traditional Plan (PPO/HMO)

%

Personal & Tax Assumptions

Used to calculate tax savings on HSA contributions.

%

Your estimate of gross medical costs before insurance.

Up to the IRS limit ($4,150 individual / $8,300 family for 2024).

How long do you plan to hold these funds?

Analysis Results

HSA Plan Wins

HSA Plan Net Cost

$3,450
  • Annual Premiums: $4,200
  • Out-of-Pocket Cost: $2,000
  • Tax Savings: -$750
  • Employer Credits: -$500

Traditional Plan Net Cost

$6,800
  • Annual Premiums: $6,000
  • Out-of-Pocket Cost: $800
  • Tax Savings: $0
  • Employer Credits: $0

Liquidity & Risk

The HSA plan requires $2,500 more in available cash to cover your deductible in a worst-case scenario. Ensure your emergency fund is sufficient.

Tax Advantage

By choosing the HSA plan, you are generating an immediate 18% effective reduction in your health costs through tax avoidance.

Understanding HSA Strategy

The Triple Tax Advantage

HSAs are the most tax-efficient vehicle in the US code. Contributions are tax-deductible (pre-tax), growth is tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free. Unlike an FSA, these funds never expire.

HSA vs. Traditional Plan Tradeoffs

Traditional plans (PPO/HMO) offer "first-dollar" coverage with lower deductibles but higher monthly premiums. HSA-eligible plans (HDHPs) trade higher upfront risk for lower premiums and significant tax savings. The "best" plan depends on your expected medical usage and cash reserves.

Common HSA Misconceptions

Many believe an HSA is "use it or lose it"—that is an FSA. HSA funds are yours forever, even if you change jobs. Another myth is that you can't use HSA funds for dental or vision; in reality, most qualified medical, dental, and vision expenses are covered.

Other Health Insurance Tools

Health Plan Cost Comparator

Compare two plans side-by-side across all scenarios.

Open tool

Medical Usage Simulator

Model potential costs for specific surgeries, chronic care, or life events.

Open tool

Medical Cash Exposure Tool

Identify your total liquid cash needed for emergencies.

Open tool