Compare deductible options by estimating long-term cost and cash exposure for homeowners insurance.
Homeowners claims are less frequent but much larger than auto claims.
At a 5% annual claim probability over 10 years, the lower expected cost is: Option B.
Break-even Insight: You would need to file a claim every 8.5 years for the lower deductible to be the cheaper choice.
Your cash reserves fully cover the alternative deductible exposure.
A calm, analytical approach to insurance decisions.
Unlike auto insurance, where minor fender-benders are common, homeowners insurance is primarily designed for low-probability, high-severity events. Most homeowners will go decades without a major claim. This makes the "expected cost" of a high deductible significantly lower over a 10-to-20 year horizon, provided you have the cash reserves to handle a sudden $5,000 or $10,000 hit.
Choosing a higher deductible doesn't just save you the immediate difference in premium. It also creates a natural barrier against filing small claims that could lead to premium surcharges or non-renewal. By self-insuring smaller risks, you maintain a "clean" insurance profile, which has a tangible financial value that standard calculators often ignore.
As home values and construction costs rise, your total coverage increases. Many policies automatically adjust these values annually. Periodically reviewing your deductible ensures that your "skin in the game" remains proportionate to your overall financial health and the current replacement cost of your asset.
Analyze your geographic risk for fire, flood, and wind to determine if your current policy limits are sufficient for total loss scenarios.
Open ToolCalculate the ideal liquid reserve needed to cover both your insurance deductible and common non-insured home maintenance emergencies.
Open ToolA step-by-step logic engine to help you decide whether to file a specific claim or pay out-of-pocket to protect your future premiums.
Open Tool